Montreal real estate and household incomes

Rob Carrick from the Globe & Mail is back at with an article entitled "Can you afford a home in these cities?" I love how Rob keeps it real and puts things in a comparative perspective. Rob again applies his Real Life Ratio indicator when looking at home affordability in various Canadian cities. According to him, "Montreal's a trouble spot, with actual household income well below the estimated income required to carry the average home." I would agree with him that "Falling prices would help some prospective home buyers, but its not a big factor as you'd expect." I also agree that if the Real Life Ratio, i.e. the common sense calculation for owning a home doesn't work then it's okay to rent or save on building a large down payment.

Mike Holmes' magazine on mortgages & the buying process

This past weekend I was reorganizing my chaotic office and came across an old issue of Mike Holmes' magazine. In it there was an interesting article about first time buyers called "The first time home buyer's guide" published in the May 2011 edition. In the article Nathalie Rodriquez outlines a step-by-step process to buying your first home. Some of the content jumps between content relevant to Ontario residents and US citizens hence I have translated the information into what is important in Quebec plus added my two cents.


Save cash to build a down payment nest egg. Clearly this shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. We've discussed this issue on several radio shows and I've blogged about it.

Get a pre-approval letter. I agree a pre-approval is critical as it is an initial review of your finances, credit and ideally creates proper budget for a buying that first property.

• (A) All banks and mortgage insurers in Canada base their income to debt ratio based on your "total debt service ratio" or TDS. The TDS accounts for your gross declared income and takes a walk into the future by accounting for annual future mortgage payments, property taxes, home heating, and all outstanding debts. In short, between 42-44% of your gross income can be diverted to managing these total debts. Clearly the TDS calculation does not account for all household debt and other personal obligations. I like how the article emphasizes other debts and obligations but also future anticipated debts. This is something I always try to explain and drive home to clients that are looking to buy. Buying has to make sense now but also in the future. 

• (B) Another great point the article mentions is that if you have a pre-approval with a bank you are not obligated to stick with them. The only time pre-approval becomes binding is when your mortgage actually becomes notarized. Something not mentioned is that even if you've signed for the mortgage in-branch it isn't binding yet either. I have a client that went to "mortgage signing" at a branch and was so badly taken care of that she walked out and we moved the mortgage to a virtual lender that same day. 

• (C) A pre-approval I will add also is very helpful in that any problem areas such as credit, income taxes owed and filing your taxes can be quickly identified and addressed. Nothing worse than being under a financing deadline for a purchase and losing that dream house because your paperwork wasn't in order.

Work with a realtor and start house hunting. Find the right realtor that genuinely works with you. Don't be shy and interview realtors if you must. Also, Buying your first time house is a contact sport. In other words, get out there and see what you like and don't like. I also like how the article mentions to shop smart.  Do your homework on the property and area, i.e. drive past it during the night, get a feel for the road traffic around, research the quality of schools in the area, check out neighborhood websites. If any major renovations have been completed why not research the permit history.

Order an inspection & make an offer. A proper inspection can take 3 to 4 hours and you should have a report in your hands within a few days. The report should outline any fixes, current problems or even potential future problems. Rodriquez is correct in that both lenders and insurer won't provide a mortgage on a property if there are major issues such as foundation concerns. Given my experience if your inspection report highlights major foundation issues and your go back to the vendor to adjust the price, the bank will probably see the price amendment and they could ask questions. Rodriquez is not a fan of offering more than asking price. I agree that this could go against your pre-approval and all prior budgeting. Second, don't feel pressured by anyone. Keep in mind that there are many other options out there on the market. More and more properties will be put on the market in the coming weeks.

If you've never put in an offer on a house your real estate broker hopefully will help you out. With your inspection completed you may also be able to renegotiate that offer price. Don't be afraid to request a final walk through before closing at notary. Ensure that the property is in the same condition that you saw when you made your initial offer.

Closing & occupancy (aka act of sale or notary). A week or two prior to the closing date on the property your notary will call you to book your appointment and give a check list of things to bring with you (photo ID, certificate of location and proof of property insurance). Some notaries host one meeting for the title and hyothecary loan, while most will split them up into two separate meetings.

Overall Nathalie Rodriquez's article is useful for first time buyers. Some of the article is confusing as she flips between US and Ontario-relevant content. Having said that I like that she distinguishes between going with a bank or mortgage broker. I disagree with her point that through a mortgage broker banks won't be as willing to overlook credit issues. Lastly, I completely disagree with her that through a mortgage broker mortgage terms can be "riskier." As a mortgage broker I look out for my client's interests now but also help them plan for the future. Your not gonna get that experience at the bank.

I'm thinking of buying. Where can down payment come from?

That's right! We're slowing headed into another buying season in Quebec. Many Quebecers and Canadians alike are contemplating the sale of their property or perhaps that first purchase. This blog entry will focus on the latter. First time home buyers are my favorite clients to work with. Maybe it's the former teacher within me that's speaking. There is so much information to share and discuss. I often read the Globe & Mail, and I think the timing of Robert McLister's article on down payments is important to review. 

If you're looking to buy a primary home, condo or duplex for yourself then you will still need a minimum of 5% down. So the question is where can down payment originate from? Here is a down payment quick snapshot:

1. Many people like to tap into their RRSPs with the Home Buyer's Plan (HBP). As a first time buyer you are permitted to use up to $25,000 per person. after buying you have a 2 year grace period upon which your 3rd year you will need to reimburse 1/15 of your amount borrowed. Rob is very correct in that bank's do not take into account that new future debt as part of their TDS calculation but also future debt planning. In other words think twice about using your RRSPs as some Canadians are having trouble repaying that loan.

2. Some folks with generous family members (parents, brother, sister, grandparents) provide a down payment gift. This remains fairly popular given the price of homes. Rob is right in that banks try to ensure that the cash is genuinely a gift rather than a personal loan. This is something that is challenging to monitor after the purchase.

3. In my opinion, building up your personal savings is still the best way to create down payment. Yes it is slow and old fashioned but less potential headaches later.

4. If you are pressed to buy and are low on down payment, in certain circumstances banks will permit you to dip into your credit cards and personal line(s) of credit for the missing down payment. The banks refer to this as alternative sources of down payment. Rob is correct to highlight that the borrower(s) must be well qualified, i.e. great credit, good job. Also, borrowing money towards your down payment has to make financial sense given the your overall indebtedness increases and that needs to be taken into account. In such circumstances approving such mortgages are case-by-case and not the norm.

Once upon a time prior to 2012 mortgage changes, many people took advantage of the "cash-back mortgage" programs. In such cases, the bank would give your 5% down in exchange for paying a much higher 5 year fixed rate. Usually the bank of Canada posted rate. In essence, you self-finance the cash back. However, the penalties for such mortgages should you sell or refinance are costly as you are expected to reimburse some or all of the original cash-back.  If you have such a mortgage, ride out your term before refinancing unless the penalties aren't an issue.

Stay on course with the right financial and mortgage plan

I agree with Rob's sentiment throughout his article in that buying a home without having  properly saved down payment and with having the right financial/mortgage plan is risky.

_____________________________________
McLister, Robert "Canadians can still buy a house without saving their pennie" Published Monday, Jan. 07 2013, The Globe & Mail.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/personal-finance/mortgages/canadians-can-still-buy-a-house-without-saving-their-pennies/article6970799/

What’s my buying capacity? Maximum versus reasonable

Probably the number one question I get asked as a mortgage broker is “Hey Mark, what’s my buying capacity?” As a first time buyer or even a repeat buyer your buying capacity is mission critical. With my weekly column in the Hudson Gazette and my blog montrealmortgageblogger.com, I’ve received quite a few calls from home owners that are over their heads with mortgage and debt payments. It’s always good for the ego to see our maximum buying capacity, but does it make sense to stretch it that high? I will tell you from several horror stories that I’ve seen the past three weeks, clearer it’s not worth it.  

Your buying capacity is based on a couple mortgage calculations, one in particular referred at TDS or Total Debt Service ratio. Typically all Canadian banks use this calculation. This calculation takes a look at your annual expenses namely school and municipal taxes, home heating, and your personal debt load and is divided by your gross income (combined if you are a couple and a portion of your rental income, if any) multiplied by one hundred. On an insured purchase meaning your putting less than 20% down payment, your TDS can go up to 44%. Depending on the lender a refinance the TDS can range from 40-44% whether you are refinancing conventionally (up to 80% of market value of your home) or insured (85% of market value).

First and foremost if you are buying or refinancing mortgage planning is invaluable. You will not always get that detailed service at the branch-level at a bank. That statement is not intended knock the banks but one needs to be careful and budget conscious. A good mortgage broker can help you establish a plan and keep you on budget. What I mean by that is take a much closer look at that TDS calculation. TDS is a crude ratio and does not take into account a lot of your other annual expenses such as insurance, school tuition for the kids, food, gas, etc. With that in mind you can create a reasonable buying capacity. Lastly, when taking your income into account typically I look solely at base incomes and if appropriate exclude or take an average of your over time, bonuses and commission. I treat those as sugar because they can all disappear or fluctuate tremendously in this economy.

If you have any questions or would like to share a mortgage experience, I’d love to hear from you. Have a great week.

As a new homebuyer, can renovations costs be rolled into my mortgage?

Welcome to the new winter buying season. Yes, I know I said the “w-word” already, i.e. winter. If you are thinking of buying a new home for next spring or summer then it’s not a bad idea to plan a little ahead. My next couple articles in the coming weeks will focus on home buying. There are three types of construction and renovations mortgages. First, there is a self-built home where you require multiple cash disbursements, a “turnkey” construction where the home would be built by a certain date with one disbursement and finally a purchase with renovations. This week I’d like to focus on the third type, buying a home and rolling renovations costs into the mortgage. 

For example, I had a recent client that bought a home in Vaudreuil-Dorion.This client loved the house but it needed a little TLC in the kitchen and wood floors throughout the first floor. Most bank products of this nature permit you to buy the home and you can make renovations between 5-20% of the purchase amount for a maximum of $40,000. This renovations portion simply gets added on top of the mortgaged amount. If you exceed $40,000 it is still possible to get the funds needed but at that point it is typically seen as a construction loan as the renovations required would be considered major at that point. 

It’s also a good idea to be as clear with yourself with what type of renovations you really would like to do and make sure that the money spent actually adds bang and value to the home. This latter point is important.You probably have a pretty good idea of your personality and what your future plans will be. Some clients will make the purchase with renovations with the expectation to hang onto the home for the medium to long term which is fine. However if you are expecting to refinance in the future here is where the value-added will be important.

If you have any specific questions you’d like to discuss in next week’s article please feel free to email me.

Are you thinking of buying your first home?

The winter buying season is slowly upon us. If you’rethinking of buying your first home now is a good time to start planning ahead. Agood place to start is by putting aside some money towards a downpayment.Ideally, you need a minimum of 5% down for a home. If you don’t have exactly 5%then there are cash-back mortgage options available. In addition to downpayment,banks like to see that you have 1.5% of the purchase price meaning closingcosts such as notary fees and welcome taxes.

With some downpayment in hand you are now ready to getpre-approved. In other words, a pre-approval will access your buying capacity.Often times clients are anxious to know their buying capacity. That’s normal butit’s important to look closer into those numbers. A good rule of thumb is toask yourself, are these mortgage payments (including heat, property taxes,insurance) reasonable and sustainable for me over the next 5 years or so? Moreoften than not, I see clients that come to see me after they have bought andthey find themselves over-extended with mortgage payments and personal debts. Second,the pre-approval process will help identify any trouble areas that can hinderyour ability to buy (such as bad or no credit) but often such areas can befixed. This can take time but get you eventually into a position to buy.

With pre-approval inhand, I suggest meeting with a real estate broker. From there the home shoppingprocess can begin with a good foundation. 

If you have any specific questions you’d like to discuss innext week’s article please feel free to email me.